CS 6470: Notes on Site Choice & Appropriate Behavior

A Place Where You Can Really Participate

To be a participant observer on a site, you need to really participate. If you are studying a karaoke site, you had better start singing! As you pick a site to study, make sure it's one where you are comfortable participating.

A Place People Want to Talk About

Imagine you are a member of the site. If someone asked if you wanted to talk about it, would you be excited to chat? If people care about the site, you will have an easier time getting people to talk with you.

Messaging

Make sure your site has a way to send a message to an individual user. It will be too hard to recruit participants if it does not. Make sure there is no rule against sending unsolicted direct messages to other users. (Many Discord servers object to people DMing others.)

If You are Considering a 'Dark' Site

There are many wonderful, cheerful, upbeat, appropriate sites to study. Places where people make music together, or discuss important issues. For most people, studying a site like that is the right choice. There are also some dark, scary places online, where users do the most shocking things. Generally, we discourage students from studying sites like that. But we don't forbid it. If you choose to do so, there are some things to think about:

1. Don't underestimate how stressful it can be to study a 'dark' site. One colleague told me a story of a student in his class trying to study such a site and ultimately hating the whole experience and saying that he/she "felt dirty" for being there.
2. Expect to be attacked verbally, and possibly have some of your personal information found online, revealed, and mocked.
• You should not respond to any attacks leveled against you--even to just 'set the record straight.' Trolls/harassers are looking for a reaction. Responding generally makes things worse. If this happens to you, do not reply to the troll, and contact the instructor and TA for guidance on how to proceed.
3. Remember that in doing this study, you must continue to behave in a fashion appropriate for a GT student. For anything you do online, imagine showing it to your family and saying "this is what I'm doing in class" and feeling good about that. Imagine showing it to the president of Georgia Tech, or to a reporter for an Atlanta paper. What you do for class has to be appropriate.

This creates a methodological problem. If you really want to do participant observation with hooligans, then you have to become a hooligan. But for assigned class work, you can't become a hooligan. You represent GT in what you do for your project. Most importantly, under no circumstances can you participate in anything illegal or obscene, or seem to be doing so.

Studying a site like this requires a lot of maturity, a thick skin, and a cool temper. Think hard about what you're getting into.

A Place Where You Are Comfortable Revealing Who You Are

You must reveal who you are and use your real name as part of your login on the site you study. Not doing so requires special permission from the instructor. You are revealing to people on your site that you are a researcher studying them. If you're not comfortable doing that on your site, you may want to think about picking another site.

A Note on Existing Accounts (Especially Reddit)

If you are studying Reddit, people may not take you seriously (may not respond to you) if your account is too new or has too little karma. If you can use an established account with karma, that helps. However, examine your past posting history. If in the past you have posted radical or not safe for work (NSFW) content, then people may judge you by your posting history.

If you think this might apply to you, create a new account as soon as possible. Try to build up just a bit of karma on the new account (100 is good).

This is mainly for Reddit, but may apply to other sites as well.