Erdös Numbers for Computer Graphics Researchers
If you have an interest in mathematics, you have probably heard about the
prolific mathematician Paul Erdös. It has become a pastime in
the math community to find out how many links through co-authored papers
it takes to get from a given mathematician to Erdös. Co-authors of
Erdös
have an Erdös Number of one, co-authors of his co-authors have an
Erdös
number of two, and so on.
Because computer graphics is founded on mathematics, it should come as no
surprise that a number of computer graphics researchers have low
Erdös
numbers. If you are a graphics researcher, how can you find your own
Erdös number? One way is to try the MathSciNet collaboration
distance calculator. I have not actually not had much luck with this
method for graphics researchers, however, most likely because the database
does not
containing many graphics publications. A better way is to start with the
list
of co-authors and
co-co-authors of Erdös. It is a long list, but a few of the people on
this list publish in the graphics community:
Agarwal, Pankaj Kumar
Bern, Marshall W.
Chazelle, Bernard M.
Dey, Tamal Krishna
Dobkin, David P.
Edelsbrunner, Herbert
Guibas, Leonidas J.
Hughes, John F.
Mitzenmacher, Michael
O'Rourke, Joseph
Snoeyink, Jack Scott
Each of the above people have an Erdös Number of two, and they all have
collaborated with a number of people in graphics. Note that many of them
are computational geometers, which is a subject that forms a bridge
between math and graphics. Using the
DBLP
Bibliography Server, I picked
out some names in the graphics field from their co-author
lists. The ACM Digital Library
would be another good way to find such co-authors.
The indented names below each have an Erdös Number of three.
If you publish in graphics, you probably can find someone among
them who is a short hop from you.
Agarwal, Pankaj Kumar
Brooks, Frederick P., Jr.
Cohen, Jonathan D.
Metaxas, Dimitris
Turk, Greg → Jessica Hodgins
Varshney, Amitabh
Bern, Marshall W.
Amenta, Nina
Grimm, Cindy
Chazelle, Bernard M.
Kazhdan, Michael → Hugues Hoppe
Rusinkiewicz, Szymon → Marc Levoy
Tal, Ayellet
Dey, Tamal Krishna
Bajaj, Chandrajit
Zorin, Denis
Dobkin, David P.
Finkelstein, Adam → Michael F. Cohen
Funkhouser, Thomas → Pat Hanrahan
Silver, Deborah
Sweldens, Wim
Edelsbrunner, Herbert
Hamann, Bernd
Lin, Ming C.
Manocha, Dinesh
Guibas, Leonidas J.
Adams, Bart
Gross, Markus → Heung-Yeung "Harry" Shum
Pai, Dinesh
Pauly, Mark
Pottmann, Helmut
Salesin, David → Donald Greenberg
Seidel, Hans-Peter
Veach, Eric
Hughes, John F.
Aliaga, Daniel
Barr, Alan
Barzel, Ronen
Cani, Marie-Paule
Durand, Fredo
Igarashi, Takeo
Ju, Tao
Laidlaw, David
Markosian, Lee
Matusik, Wojciech
McGuire, Morgan
Nayar, Shree
Pfister, Hanspeter
Raskar, Ramesh
van Dam, Andries
Zeleznik, Robert
Mitzenmacher, Michael
Marks, Joe
Owens, John
Sharf, Andrei
O'Rourke, Joseph
Badler, Norman
Snoeyink, Jack Scott
Alliez, Pierre
Isenberg, Martin
Lindstrom, Peter
van de Panne, Michiel
Pascucci, Valerio
Rossignac, Jarek
Shewchuk, Jonathan
The above list has been augmented by links (→) to a few
prolific graphics authors who have an Erdös Number of four.
Erdös-Bacon Numbers
In the entertainment industry, the equivalent of the Erdös Number is
the Kevin Bacon Number. This is the number of links through feature films
that it takes to reach the actor Kevin Bacon. An actor who was in a film
with Kevin Bacon has a Bacon Number of one, and so on. There is, of course,
a Bacon Number calculator, The
Oracle of Bacon.
There is a small
group of people who have both an Erdös Number and a Bacon Number, and
the sum of these numbers is their Erdös-Bacon number. Believe it or not,
there is a
Wikipedia page on this topic.
Bernard Chazelle has a Bacon number of three (via the movie "Guy and
Madeline on a Park Bench"), and an Erös number of two, giving him an
Erdös-Bacon number of five. There are several researchers in
graphics who have been extras on films, giving them Erdös-Bacon
numbers. Randy Pausch had a part in the 2009 film Star Trek, in which the
actor John Cho also appeared. John Cho was in the 2007 movie The Air I
Breath with Kevin Bacon, which gives Randy Pausch a Bacon number of two.
Since Randy's Erdös number is four, his Erdös-Bacon number is
six. Dan Goldman was an extra on Star Wars II with Rose Byrne, giving him
a Bacon number of two, and an Erdös-Bacon number of six. Eric
Enderton was an extra on Star Wars I, which gives him a Bacon number of
three, and an Erdös-Bacon number of seven.
Lower Bound
Finally, I will end with a discussion of possible lower bounds on
Erdös-Bacon numbers. The following text is from Wikipedia's entry
on the topic, which was deleted in 2009 due to overzealous editing:
Erdös himself may have an Erdös–Bacon number of 3, 4, or 6.
Erdös' Erdös number is 0 by definition, and his Bacon number is
currently 4 according to data from the Internet Movie Database. However,
one of the links is disputed on the Erdös Number Project website.
Without this link, his Bacon number rises to 6. Also, Sir Alec Guinness
appears in N is a Number with Erdös. Although Guinness' name is not
in the credits, this gives Erdös a Bacon-Erdös number of 3.
Daniel Kleitman, a mathematician at MIT, was an advisor for the movie
Good Will Hunting and appeared briefly as an uncredited extra. Minnie
Driver, who appeared in that movie, also appeared in Sleepers with Kevin
Bacon; as such, Kleitman's Bacon number is 2. He also coauthored a paper
with Erdös. This gives him an Erdös–Bacon number of 3.
The only ways a lower Erdös-Bacon number could be achieved would be:
- for an individual who had co-authored an academic paper with Paul
Erdös to appear in a movie with Kevin Bacon, giving all involved an
Erdös–Bacon number of 2;
- for Bacon to co-author an academic paper with someone with an
Erdös number of 1, which would give Bacon an Erdös–Bacon number of 2;
- for anyone who appeared in the documentary N is a Number along
with Erdös to appear in a film with Bacon, which would posthumously
give Erdös an Erdös–Bacon number of 2;
- for Kevin Bacon to appear in a film that also uses stock footage of
Erdös, giving Erdös an Erdös–Bacon number of 1;
- for a heretofore unknown joint academic paper by Bacon and Erdös to be
published, giving Bacon an Erdös–Bacon number of 1;
- for Kevin Bacon and Paul Erdös to be revealed as being the same
person, giving him an Erdös–Bacon number of 0.
Greg Turk, July 2009,
Updated November 2014